I’ve always been a believer of the Fatima apparitions. However, in the last 20 years or so, I’ve had to look at the events from another point of view to keep from having to abandon it all together. Things just didn’t add up, but that’s because I didn’t have all the facts.
I found out that it was not Our Lady who said that the 3rd secret was to be read by the pope in 1960. This is huge considering there was no pope in 1960. I know Catholics who’ve abandoned Fatima over this one point. I gave the best answer I could think of in The Hidden Message of Fatima.
When Lucia fell seriously ill in 1943, the Leiria-Fatima bishop commanded her to write down the third part of the secret. Sister Lucia was with the Dorothean Sisters in Tuy, Spain, when all this happened.
There was an agreement with the Bishop of Leiria-Fatima that the document “would not be opened before 1960, or only after Lucia’s death.” Sister Lucia said recently that it was she and not Our Lady who set that date. [1] She probably set the date because she told Fr. Augustin Feuntes in 1957 that Our Lady had told her that the great chastisement will happen by 1960.
The next hurdle was the collegial consecration of Russia and its conversion.
On July 13th 1917, Our Lady said to the Children, “You see Hell, where the souls of poor sinners go. To save them God wishes to establish in the world the devotion to my Immaculate Heart. If they do what I will tell you, many souls will be saved, and there will be peace. The war is going to end. But if they do not stop offending God, another and worse one will begin in the reign of Pius XI. When you see a night illuminated by an unknown light, know that is the great sign God gives you that He is going to punish the world for its crimes by means of war, of hunger, and of persecution of the Church and of the Holy Father. To prevent this I come to ask the consecration of Russia to My Immaculate Heart and the Communion of reparation on the first Saturdays. If they listen to my requests, Russia will be converted and there will be peace. If not she will scatter her errors through the world, provoking wars and persecutions of the Church. The good will be martyred, the Holy Father will have much to suffer [Jacinta later had more visions concerning a future Pope’s suffering], various nations will be annihilated. In the end My Immaculate Heart will triumph. The Holy Father will consecrate Russia to Me, and it will be converted and a certain period of peace will be granted to the world. In Portugal the dogma of the Faith will always be kept.”
Many good Catholics have interpreted “Russia will be converted” to mean it will be converted to Catholicism.
I’ve never held to this interpretation. I believe Our Lady meant that it will be saved from Communism. The key words are “and there will be peace.” It would be naïve to think peace in this context meant total and absolute. There will never be that kind of peace on earth.
The context was about Communism and peace from it. Russia wasn’t Catholic before the Bolshevik Revolution and hadn’t been Catholic for a thousand years. Later apparitions and messages prove my point.
Sister Lucia continued to have visions in 1925 and 1929. It was in Tuy, Spain in 1929 where she received another message about Russia and the collegial consecration.
We must pay close attention to the words used by Our Lord, Our Lady, and Lucia.
The 1929 message: The moment has come for God to ask the Holy Father to make, in union with all the bishops of the world, the consecration of Russia to my Immaculate Heart. He promises to save Russia by this means. There are so many souls that the justice of God condemns for sins committed against me, that I have come to ask for reparation. Sacrifice yourself for this intention and pray.
The words of Our Lady were “save Russia” not “convert Russia.” I believe that Our Lady meant save it from Communism, which was the cause for the persecution of Catholics. Many of them were put in gulags and suffered greatly. Churches were destroyed and Catholicism was outlawed. Nations were annihilated into the Soviet Union, such as Ukraine, Belarus, Lithuania, Estonia, and ten other nations. See Our Lady’s Fatima Message and the Consecration of Russia
Lucia wrote in 1929, “Later on , through an intimated communication, Our Lord complained: ‘They have not chosen to heed my request … As the King of France, they will regret it and then will do it, but it will be late. Russia will already have spread her errors throughout the world, provoking wars and persecutions against the Church. The Holy Father will have much to suffer.’”
According to Lucia, Our Lord was clearly talking about Russia falling into Communism and spreading it around the world.
In 1935, Lucia wrote, “Our Lord was very displeased because His request had not been attended to and I made this fact known to the Bishop in a letter. Until now, Our Lord has asked nothing more from me than prayers and sacrifices. From an intimated conversation with Him, it seems that He is ready to show mercy towards Russia as He promised five years ago and which He wishes so much to save.”
Of course, Our Lord desires that Russia become Catholic again, but He desires the whole world to be Catholic. Why not consecrate the whole world and make it all Catholic? Why just Russia? This makes no sense and that’s because the message concerns Communism, which is one of the greatest threats to Catholicism. It was never about converting Russia to Catholicism.
In 1936, it was Lucia who said, “He would not convert Russia without the Holy Father making that consecration.” She wrote that Jesus told her: “Pray much for the Holy Father. He will do it, but it will be late. Nevertheless, the Immaculate Heart of Mary will save Russia. It was has been entrusted to her.” [2]
Jesus twice uses the words “save Russia.” Our Lady used the word “converted” twice in 1917, but used the word “save” in 1929. What was truly meant when Our Lady said, “Russia will be converted?” If it’s the Catholic Faith, then I believe it’s a false apparition. I might be going out on a limb here, but it just ain’t happening. Russia will never be a Catholic nation again.
In 1952 when Pope Pius XII consecrated Russia without all the bishops, Lucia stated, “I am grieved that it has not been carried out as Our Lady had asked. Patience!…Let us hope that Our Lady, as a good Mother, will be pleased to accept it.”
The end result was that Russia converted out of Communism. The nations that were annihilated into the Soviet Union resumed their sovereignty. A certain period of peace came to those Catholics from their once persecution from the Communists. Russia did spread its errors to China where Catholics are persecuted to this very day.
Because the consecration was late and not done correctly, the full effect of peace from Communism was not realized.
To believe in Fatima, it seems this is the only logical interpretation. Nothing else works unless you don’t believe we’re in the great apostasy and Catholicism will resume some of its glory in the future. The problem is the time period. It’s been over a hundred years and it’s getting worse, not better. Belief that Russia will be converted to the Catholic faith is futile.
Our Lady said Russia will convert, but there is no true pope to make the consecration correctly and we’re in the great apostasy. It would be extremely odd that a whole nation would convert to Catholicism while no other Catholic nation exists and when the Church itself goes through its great dark night of betrayal from its own. Not to mention, Russia is staunchly “Russian Orthodox.”
The last hurdle is “In Portugal the dogma of the Faith will always be kept.” I don’t know what dogma that Our Lady is referring to. It would seem that she was referring to the whole Catholic Faith. Perhaps, “always be kept” simply means always kept from the Masonic government (which took over in 1910) trying to wipe it out completely and/or kept free from being outlawed as Communism did to it in Russia.
Footnotes:
[1] The info comes from: https://www.marian.org/marianhelper/issues/issue90/article9067.html
It would seem the fake Lucia made the claim but there’s no verifiable evidence that Our Lady ever said the “pope of 1960” was to read the secret.
[2] Memoirs and Letters of Sister Lucia