Lutherans, Anglicans and Methodists say the Apostles Creed claiming the church is one, holy, catholic, and apostolic.
Contrary to Catholicism’s definition, oneness or unity simply means the Church made up by believers across denominational lines are united to Christ. There is no formal unity. It doesn’t require a unity of faith in all doctrine, but a merely an acceptance of Christ as Lord and Savior with some basic beliefs surrounding Christianity. There’s no definition as to what constitutes what beliefs are necessary. However, if there was a denial of hell, Christ’s divinity, or Trinity, you may not be considered by these particular Protestants as Christians united to Christ.
Vatican 2 redefined the nature of the Church by promulgating this Protestant understanding. The Vatican 2 religion through its popes promote this Protestant understanding in decrees, letters, addresses, and other documents, such as the Balamand Statement and the Joint Declaration with Lutherans.
In Lumen Gentium, Vatican 2 declared:
“This is the one Church of Christ which in the Creed is professed as one, holy, catholic and apostolic…”
According to same Vatican 2 religion, this Church of Christ is also formally divided and not unified in faith.
In Unitatis Redintegratio, Vatican 2 declared:
4. “Nevertheless, the divisions among Christians prevent the Church from realizing in practice the fullness of Catholicity proper to her, in those of her sons and daughters who, though attached to her by baptism, are yet separated from full communion with her. Furthermore, the Church herself finds it more difficult to express in actual life her full Catholicity in all its bearings.”
This statement makes no sense unless Vatican 2 is saying the Eastern Orthodox and Protestants and their false religions make up the Church of Christ. However, the Vatican 2 popes have removed all doubt that this, indeed, is what Vatican 2 means:
In 1972, Paul VI addressed the newly elected Patriarch of Constantinople a telegram saying: “At the moment when you assume a heavy charge in the service of the Church of Christ…” (L’Osservatore Romano, July 27, 1972, p. 12)
In a 2006 Joint Declaration with the Eastern Orthodox, Benedict XVI referred to Patriarch Bartholomew and himself “as Pastors in the Church of Christ.” (www.zenit.org, Zenit news report, Nov. 30, 2006)
The following year in the Common Declaration with the Eastern Orthodox, Benedict XVI referred to Archbishop Chrysostomos II and himself “as Pastors in the Church.”
That same year Benedict XVI’s told the Eastern Orthodox Romanian Patriarchate: “I also wish to express my earnest good wishes for you and your brother Bishops as you guide the Church in this time of transition.”
In a Jan. 22, 2013 L’Osservatore Romano article titled: The divisions among Christians disfigure the face of the Church, it was written that Benedict XVI said, “One of the gravest sins ‘that disfigure the Church’s face’ is the sin ‘against her visible unity’.”
On May 25, 1995, John Paul II, in Ut Unum Sint, n. 59, approved the 1993 Balamand declaration, which declared:
14. It is in this perspective that the Catholic Churches and the Orthodox Churches recognize each other as Sister Churches, responsible together for maintaining the Church of God in fidelity to the divine purpose, most especially in what concerns unity. According to the words of Pope John Paul II, the ecumenical endeavour of the Sister Churches of East and West, grounded in dialogue and prayer, is the search for perfect and total communion which is neither absorption nor fusion but a meeting in truth and love (cf. Slavorum Apostoli, n. 27).
According to this statement, the visible Church of God is divided and the Eastern Orthodox churches form the one Church of God.
The Nov. 1, 1999 Joint Declaration on the Doctrine of Justification by the Lutheran World Federation and the Catholic Church states:
44. We give thanks to the Lord for this decisive step forward on the way to overcoming the division of the church. We ask the Holy Spirit to lead us further toward that visible unity which is Christ’s will.
Again, we see the rejection of the dogma on the visible unity of the Church and the heresy that Lutherans are part of the Body of Christ the Church. John Paul II approved and blessed the Joint Declaration.
The Vatican 2 religion and popes hold the Protestant-style oneness doctrine opposed to the Catholic definition.
The Catholic doctrine of oneness is so foundational, deviation from it amounts to an avalanche of heresies. The Trinity is one, Christ is one with His Body, and the Church must be one in faith. If it were divided in faith, Christ would be divided with truth, Christ’s prayer for unity would be a failure, the true Church couldn’t be identified because it would not truly exist, the Catholic definition would be false, Scripture and particular I Tim. 3:15 would be a lie, thus making the gates of hell the prevailer of the Church and ultimately proving Christianity a false religion.
The Church is one in faith or else Christ is not Lord.
What I find astounding is how pseudo-traditionalist “Catholics” hold to the same heretical principle of oneness as Vatican 2 and Protestantism. They claim to hold the oneness dogma, while outwardly being divided in faith with Vatican 2 and their pope. What blindness!
For further reading see That They May Be One (Ut Unum Sint)
The Church has never lost its unity, even after the “Orthodox”, Protestants and Modernists have left it.
Happy new year Steven ! God bless you, your family and the Holy Roman Catholic Church !
Same to you. Happy New Year and Feast of the Circumcision of Our Lord!
It is worth considering the idea that God, acting to preserve His own dignity, knowing the hearts of men, has allowed Vatican II so that the perpetrators so prevalent in today’s “church” cannot consecrate, cannot confer the sacraments, cannot forgive sin. And as a consequence, neither can they defile what is truly God’s.
One is forced to consider the possibility that God has permitted Vatican II and its rotten fruit in order to preserve His own honor and dignity, His own Church inviolate.
Ut benedicat tibi Dominus et custodiat te!
Yes, God permittes evil because He can always draw a greater good out of it.
For those questioning unity, they must understand Unity is the same in prayer, practices, worship, sacraments, and doctrines universally. When a heresy is committed or a strange practice is performed or freedom to choose what one wants to believe or interpret is allowed, that is unity whether you directly participated or not. We do what the church wants and not what we want. Over time since VATII the NO is diametrically opposed to Catholicism and has taken on to copy Protestantism in it’s false sense of ecumenism. Thus, true Catholic unity, one of the 4 marks of the Church, is completely gone. It will take longer for NOs to come to terms with that fact that the time since VATII separation from Catholicism.